4 Best Mallet Putters For High Handicappers

If you are a high handicapper and looking for the best mallet putters for high handicappers to keep more and more putts on the line, this review is going to help you a lot.

The mallet putters with larger club heads and high MOIs are made to improve the forgiveness and efficiency of the players. However, not all mallet putters are designed to suit high handicappers.

As a high handicapper, you need to consider various features like balance, control, and playability. Since mallet putters are equally famous among players of all skill levels, they are trending in sales. You can find dozens of options introduced by top-of-line brands.

To help you filter out the best mallet putters for high handicappers I’ve reviewed the four best options. After testing various options, I’ve shortlisted the 4 options that are perfectly in line with the needs of high handicappers.

Top Best Mallet Putters For High Handicappers 2023

#1

Pinemeadow Golf Men’s PGX Putter

Specifications:

• Color: White
• Weight: 1.19 lbs
• Shaft Material: Graphite
• Size: 34 inches

Pros

• Super affordable
• Easy line alignment
• Superb balance and control

Cons

• Poor feel and sound

Buy On Amazon Buy On CBA

Pinemedow Golf Men’s putter has made its way to the top of the list. This was the first ever mallet-style putter that I got when my handicap score was 20. The putter comes at a very affordable price around 3 times lower than the Taylormade and Ping mallet putters. As a high handicapper, my biggest concern was the balance. This mallet putter uses the pendulum’s action technology that works like charm. I loved the balance and control offered by this putter.

The putter is deadly accurate and responsive as the face is spot on. The putter may feel a little heavy but after three to four strokes it doesn’t seem too heavy. It is tour weighted with a 40 g extra to 380 g standard weight. This extra weight helped me in the faster greens. The length of the putter is 34 inches.

It is slightly longer than the putter I was using before this. The extra length combined with well-aligned lines makes it super handy. Though the quality of the putter isn’t as remarkable as big brands, it is not cheaply made. The feel is acceptable and the alignment system is super handy. It is advertised as a graphite shaft but it comes with a steel shaft. The accuracy and precision of the putter are good considering the price.

The design of the putter is suitable for an inclined or arched swing plane. I have a natural swing and there I don’t face any issues. However, for more vertical hits, you need to adjust the face plane by adjusting your arms a little bit. The putter is a big bang for the buck and the only thing that I can complain about is the lack of feel and sound. The feel is not solid and it sounds like a tin can due to the steel shaft.

If you are a beginner or high handicapper and looking for a dependable mallet putter without breaking the bank this is a definite way to go. An affordable price combined with solid packs of features helps it stand among the best mallet putters for high handicappers.

Related Post: Best Blade Putters For High Handicappers

Editor’s Pick

Odyssey DFX Putter

Specifications:

• Color: Black
• Weight: 1.2 lbs Shaft
• Material: Steel

Pros

• Solid and smooth feel
• Perfectly balanced
• Highly forgiving

Cons

• Received the wrong product

Buy On Amazon Buy On CBA

As a high handicapper, you may not like the poor sound and feel of the Meadow PGX mallet putter. So the next on the list is the Odyssey PDX putter featuring a DFX insert for a smooth feel and smooth rolling. This is one of the softest inserts I’ve ever used for mallet putters.

Though it was a little more expensive than I wanted to spend, it was reviewed as one of the most dependable mallet putters I decided to give it a try. The mallet putter features various oversized grip options and lends itself to the preferences of various players.

The mallet putter is lighter than regular mallet putters available in the market.  If you were using a heavy putter before this it may take you some time to get used to its faster speed. It’s 35 inches and the grip is nice. The putter is perfectly balanced. The control is amazing. The thing I loved as a high handicapper was the sound and feel.

Its soft FDX insert enhances control and precision without limiting the feel.  The line alignment is super handy and this putter was delivered with a headcover. Unfortunately, it was delivered with an ICE insert and WINN grip. Though they sent the genuine product, later on, the exchange process took around two weeks.

Odyssey DFX putter with a perfectly balanced face, great alignment, and solid yet smooth feel stands among the best mallet putters for high handicappers. The oversized grip coupled with a highly forgiving design makes it a great option for high handicappers and beginners.

Editor’s Pick

Odyssey Golf White Hot OG Putter

Specifications:

• Specs here

Pros

• Superb feel and control
• Super comfortable grip
• Definitely improves the game

Cons

• Expensive

Buy On Amazon Buy On CBA

If you are not on a budget and looking for the most dependable mallet putter, consider the Odyssey White Hot OG putter. The putter has a soft and comfortable grip. The solid feel and crip sound feedback make it a great option for beginners.

The things that I could feel right out of the box were good weight, perfect balance, and a nice top line. It is not a heavy putter but it doesn’t feel too light. The balls come smoothly off the putter offering incredible control. The comfortable grip and perfect weight of the putter helped me alot with my inconsistent pace.

The soft face construction with perfectly balanced ergonomics helped me achieve the target and I could see the improvement right from the first stroke. It is great in both vertical and arched planes. With a little arm angle adjustment, the putter allows you to keep more putt on the line. It is available in two shaft options. You can choose from premium stepless steel and multi-material shaft.

If you’re a beginner and want to improve your game it is recommended to go with a stepless steel shaft. The soft DFX rubber grip ensures that you don’t lose comfort. Two-part inserts improve the feel and grip of the ball. It allows you to pick the ball from the greens. The only thing that I can complain about is the price. It comes with top-of-the-shelf features at a premium price point.

Odyssey Golf White Hot OG stands among the best mallet putters for high handicappers for many good reasons. Its ability to adapt to various playing styles and ultimate comfort and control makes it ideal for beginners and high handicappers who want to improve the game.

Editor’s Pick

Orlimar Golf Clubs Black-Silver F80 Mallet Style Putter

Specifications:

• Specs here

Pros

• Easy line alignment
• Comes with a quality head cover
• Big bang for the bucks

Cons

• Subpar build quality

Buy On Amazon Buy On CBA

The final option on the list of best mallet putters for high handicappers is the Orlimar F80 mallet putter. This mallet putter is an affordable option that combines plenty of functionality with a well-balanced club face for maximum forgiveness. The club in class MOI ensures smooth rolling and even the off-center strokes can hit the target.

Since it is highly forgiving, I highly recommend it for high handicappers. The oversized grip and monster (not too big) club head are my favorite features of that putter as a high handicapper. The impact off the face is soft and it grips the ball really well. Though it is a fraction of the price of high-end mallet putters, it puts an impressive roll on the golf ball.

Unlike other mallet putters in this price range, it doesn’t feel cheap in hand. The overall feel and sound feedback are quite acceptable. The face is well-balanced. The ergonomic face design coupled with an oversized rectangular grip takes its playability to a whole new level. All these features helped me keep more and more putts on the line and I could see a significant improvement in my game.

Straight-line graphics helped me line up shots more accurately. Since it is an affordable option it doesn’t feature a remarkable build quality. The paint job is junk and the paint started chipping off after a few games. The sound feedback isn’t impressive but for this price, it does a great job.

If you don’t want to spend a bunch of dollars on a highly forgiving mallet putter, this option by Orlimar is a great option. With straight-line graphics, a well-balanced face design, and impressive weight distribution around the head it stands among the best mallet putters for high handicappers.

Difference Between Mallet Putters And Blade Putters

The biggest difference between the blade and mallet putter lies in the face design. The face design of the mallet putter focuses on forgiveness while the blade putter focuses more on playability and feedback. Mallet putters are suitable for high handicappers as they are more forgiving and allow players to keep more putts on the line.

The advanced mallet putters are also famous among pro players and amateurs as they combine forgiveness and playability and ensure the golfers that they are lined up to their spot. Blade putters tend to be lighter and more playable and the club face tends to turn or twist at the impact.

The club face size of the mallet putter is quite similar to the blade putter but it has a larger sweet spot. The overall weight of the mallet putter has centered away from the face. In this way, it increases forgiveness and you keep the off-center hit on the target. However, the extra weight and larger sweet post limit the controls and playability.

Low handicappers and pro players who are skilled enough to keep the balls at the center may prefer blade putters as they are handy and more dependable. Another difference that lies between a mallet putter and a blade putter is the moment of inertia. The larger club heads on the mallet putter increase the MOI.

The increased center MOI means the club face is closer to the putt distance. In this way, it increases the forgiveness and with less precise distance control, you can keep the putt on the line. On the other hand, a lighter club head on the blade putter requires more precise distance control.

FAQs

Wrapping Up

Advanced mallet putters with advanced face balancing and more forgiving designs have made it easier to play golf for beginners and high handicappers. All the options reviewed above are tested for performance and really help the high handicappers improve the game. Here are my two favorites for best mallet putters for high handicappers:

• Pinemeadow Golf Men’s PGX Putter for superb balance and control, super affordable price, and easy line alignment.
• Odyssey Golf White Hot OG Putter for premium grade shaft material, unmatched feel and feedback, and best bar name value.

I’m hopeful that this review and information will help you make a wise decision. If you are not on a budget, it is recommended to purchase advanced mallet putters with good brand value as they serve you for a longer time and you will not outgrow them very soon.